The Outlaw John McNulty rides into the town of Nazareth on a toy horse, disguised. Upon entering the local saloon, he orders a juice pouch and enters a game of CandyLand with The Sheriff "Michael A. Keller" and The CandyLand Kid "Ryan DeNardis". When it is revealed The Outlaw has been cheating, The Sheriff removes his fake mustache, revealing his real mustache, as well as his true identity as John McNulty. Choosing to settle the matter with a duel at high noon, the two meet outside the tavern. The Sheriff put-guitars McNulty, disarming him twice. McNulty is arrested, but is freed from prison when The CandyLand Kid places an accordion outside his cell, blowing it up and creating an exit. The two ride off over the horizon as The Sheriff chases after them.